Skip to content
TwapTrade

Prediction markets vs binary options

Updated

Both pay a fixed amount if something happens and nothing if it doesn't, but they're built differently. A retail binary option is usually a bet on whether an asset's price ends above a level, with the payout set by a broker that takes the other side; a prediction market trades real-world events on a shared order book where other traders set the price. Regulators in the EU, the UK, Australia and Canada banned or restricted binary options for retail customers after heavy losses and fraud.

Prediction marketBinary option (retail)
What you tradeReal-world events: elections, matches, economic dataWhether an asset's price ends above or below a level
Who sets the priceTraders, on a shared order bookThe broker, as a fixed payout
Other side of your tradeOther tradersUsually the broker
Selling earlyYes on TwapTrade, at the market price before settlementDepends on the broker
How it's decidedRules and source named in advanceOften the broker's own platform price
Regulatory statusVaries by countryRetail sales banned or restricted in the EU, UK, Australia and Canada

Binary options and prediction markets can look alike at first: both pay a fixed amount if something happens and nothing if it doesn't. But they're built differently, and regulators treat them very differently. Here's how to tell them apart, and how to spot the scams that gave binary options their reputation.

Same payoff, different machinery

A binary option pays a set amount if a condition is met at expiry, and little or nothing if it isn't. Canada's securities regulators define it in almost exactly those terms. A typical retail binary option asks whether a currency pair, share, commodity or coin will be above a certain level at a certain time, often only minutes away.

A prediction market share has the same all-or-nothing shape. On TwapTrade, a Yes share pays $1 if the event happens and nothing if it doesn't, and shares are priced between 1¢ and 99¢.

The difference is who sets the price and who's on the other side. With most retail binary options, the broker quotes the payout and takes the other side of your trade itself, so it gains when customers lose. On a prediction market, you trade with other people on a shared order book. The price is whatever traders will pay, it works as a live estimate of the chance, and on TwapTrade you can sell at the market price any time before settlement.

Real-world events vs price moves

Binary options are mostly about short-term price moves. Prediction markets mostly ask about events: elections, match results, economic releases, court rulings and the weather. Each TwapTrade market lists its exact rules and the source used to decide it, so you know in advance how the result will be settled.

Some prediction markets also list short price questions. TwapTrade's Up or Down markets ask whether a coin's price will be higher or lower at the end of a window from 5 minutes to 1 day. They trade on the same shared order book as other markets, so other traders set the price rather than a broker, and you can sell at the market price before the window ends. They're still short-term and risky, so treat them with the same care.

Why many regulators restricted binary options

Over the past decade, regulators in several major markets decided that binary options sold to the public did more harm than good:

  • European Union: the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) prohibited marketing, distributing or selling binary options to retail clients from July 2, 2018, describing them as unsuitable for retail investors and close to gambling, and renewed the measure several times.
  • United Kingdom: the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) made its ban on selling binary options to retail consumers permanent from April 2, 2019, and warned that firms offering them to retail customers are likely to be scams.
  • Australia: the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) banned issuing and distributing binary options to retail clients from May 3, 2021, after its reviews found about 80% of retail clients lost money.
  • Canada: most provinces and territories banned offering binary options with a term of under 30 days to individuals from December 2017, citing fraud.
  • United States: the CFTC says binary options may only be offered to US customers on regulated exchanges, and it has warned, with the SEC, that many binary options websites don't follow those rules.

The common thread was short expiries, broker-set payouts, the broker on the other side of every trade, and aggressive online marketing, which together led to heavy and consistent losses.

How to spot a binary options scam

US regulators have reported complaints about platforms refusing to return customers' money, identity theft, and software rigged to produce losing trades. Warning signs include:

  • Someone you don't know contacts you by phone, email or message and points you to a trading site promising high returns.
  • Promises of guaranteed profits or risk-free trades. No honest market can promise either.
  • Pressure to deposit more, especially before you're allowed to withdraw.
  • Excuses when you try to withdraw, such as surprise fees, taxes or checks that never finish.
  • The firm isn't on your financial regulator's register, or won't say where it's based.
  • After a loss, someone offers to recover your money for a fee. That's often a second scam.

If you've been targeted, stop sending money and report it to your national financial regulator or the police.

Checking any trading site, including this one

Before you deposit anywhere, check that the service is allowed where you live, read how its markets are settled, and make sure you can see fees and the amount you'll receive before you confirm.

On TwapTrade, each market lists its exact rules and the source used to decide it, every fee is shown before you confirm, and withdrawals show the amount you'll receive before you confirm. Trading and deposits aren't offered in restricted countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Belgium, Poland, Australia, Singapore, Thailand, Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, Brazil and Argentina, plus some Canadian provinces. Browsing is open to everyone. See how it works.

Prediction markets carry real risk too. Prices are traders' estimates, not certainties, and you can lose the money you put into a trade. Nothing here is financial advice. Read prediction market risks.

Questions

Is a prediction market just a binary option?

They share a payoff shape: a fixed amount if something happens, nothing if it doesn't. The difference is that a prediction market trades real-world events with other people on a shared order book, while a retail binary option usually has a broker setting the payout and taking the other side.

Why are binary options banned in the UK and EU?

Regulators found they caused consistent losses for retail customers and were widely linked to fraud. ESMA prohibited their sale to retail clients across the EU in 2018, and the UK's FCA made its retail ban permanent in 2019.

Are binary options legal in the US?

The CFTC says binary options can only be offered to US customers on regulated US exchanges. Many websites that offer them operate outside those rules, and US regulators have warned about fraud on such sites.

Are TwapTrade's Up or Down markets binary options?

They have a similar yes-or-no payoff on a coin's price, but they trade on TwapTrade's shared order book, so other traders set the price rather than a broker who takes the other side, and you can sell at the market price before the window ends. They're still short-term and risky.

How can I check whether a trading site is legitimate?

Look it up on your national financial regulator's register, be wary of anyone who contacted you first, and never send more money just to get a withdrawal released. Guaranteed returns and withdrawal excuses are red flags.

More comparisons